(from the review by Taylor Ramsey posted on Terminal Drift, 22 October 2012)
...The digital presentation is everything a fan of the story would
hope. The regular digital comic is fine; with sharp clean scans of the
black and white art. There are a few panels where the lettering in
white on a black background is a little hard to read, but from a visual
standpoint, that is my ONLY gripe. The real discussion point here is
the audio portion and extras. This entire collection, of which there
are currently 3 issues available for download here,
is recorded with Sim doing all the characters voices and narration
himself, with music and sound effects. While not 100% successful, the
presentation works well. I can’t say Sim is a great performer, but he
makes it work. These are his creations and this mostly works well. You
know that this is how it sounds in his head. These characters are now
as close to what Dave envisioned as possible, and that is a neat
feeling. There is an odd novelty to the whole thing that may wear off,
but this is cool. The music is far from perfect as it sometimes is a
bit much, but it quickly becomes a more seamless and enjoyable part of
the book. The guided viewing experience is dynamic and extremely
effective. You move with the characters at times and the feeling of
being taken through the story rather than reading like normal can be a
bit trippy, but very fun.
The extras are exhaustive and amazing. It is clear that the DVD
extras concept is what they are going for here and there is most
everything you could have ever hoped to see, turning a 20 page comic
into a 60+ page digital DL for .99 cents. Every page, letter, note,
sketchbook or notebook page even business correspondence is included. Some of it is just an odd curiosity, but most of it is really
interesting, and out of print since the original issues or never seen at
all. Having completely forgotten the experience of reading the
individual issues years ago (I now have all the phone books and sold my
originals ages ago) this was all an unexpected treat.
For the new reader to Cerebus, this is the perfect intro and offers
up everything you would need to enter the story. As a long time reader
the new digital presentation is something even more special. There is
so much more here in the per issue package than in any other modern
comic DL, that I would be hard pressed to believe that the big boys
will even try to step up, putting this in a class by itself.
No comments:
Post a Comment